Types of ERISA Disability Benefits

A sudden illness, a car accident, or a chronic condition can change everything overnight. When paychecks stop, disability insurance becomes more than a benefit: It’s survival. For most employees, those protections fall under the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA).
If you have group disability coverage through work, your plan likely qualifies. That means your rights, your deadlines, and your appeals follow federal law. Understanding the different ERISA disability benefits—short-term, long-term, and supplemental—helps South Carolina employees know where protection begins and how to advocate when insurance companies deny coverage.
At the Peace Law Firm, attorney John Peace has spent over twenty years guiding clients through these claims. With a background in the insurance industry and decades of experience fighting against it, he knows how to cut through insurance red tape and guide you toward the benefits you earned.
What Are Short-Term ERISA Disability Benefits?
Short-term disability coverage bridges the gap when an illness or injury temporarily keeps you from working. Plans typically pay a percentage of your salary (often 40% to 70%) for a limited period, usually between a few weeks and six months.
Key features of short-term ERISA disability benefits include:
- Eligibility. Plans usually require that you have worked a minimum period, such as 90 days, before coverage begins.
- Waiting period. Benefits often start after a short elimination period, such as seven days.
- Scope of coverage. These benefits cover conditions ranging from surgical recovery to pregnancy complications.
While valuable, short-term benefits rarely provide complete financial stability. They are designed as a stopgap, not a long-term solution. For employees with lasting disabilities, transitioning into long-term coverage is often necessary.
What Are Long-Term ERISA Disability Benefits?
Long-term disability (LTD) insurance is where disputes most often arise. LTD benefits typically activate after short-term coverage ends, sometimes continuing until retirement age at 50% to 70% of your income. These benefits are vital for people facing serious illnesses, chronic conditions, or injuries that permanently alter their ability to work.
Long-term ERISA disability benefits often include:
- Extended duration. Benefits may last for years, sometimes until Social Security retirement age.
- Changing standards. Many policies define “disability” as the inability to perform your own occupation for the first 24 months, then shift to require proof that you cannot perform any occupation.
- Offsets. Insurers may reduce payments if you receive other income, such as workers’ compensation.
Due to the significant financial stakes, insurance companies often aggressively contest LTD claims. Denials and delays are common, making legal advocacy crucial.
What Other Disability Benefits Does ERISA Cover?
Beyond short- and long-term disability, ERISA can apply to other group benefit plans such as:
- Supplemental disability insurance—additional coverage that employees can buy to increase income protection;
- Employer-paid “Buy-Up” plans—options allowing employees to raise their benefit percentage; and
- Life insurance with disability riders—clauses included in some ERISA-governed life insurance that waive premiums or pay benefits in the event of disability.
Each of these is still subject to ERISA’s strict procedural rules for claims and appeals. That means federal deadlines and standards govern how disputes must be handled. At the Peace Law Firm, we work so that South Carolina employees don’t get lost in the process and have the backing to enforce their rights.
What Are Common Challenges with ERISA Disability Benefits?
Employees face recurring hurdles when pursuing ERISA disability benefits, including:
- Insurers demanding unreasonable proof or ignoring medical evidence;
- Plans using vague definitions of “disability” to deny claims;
- Claims dragging on past statutory deadlines, leaving employees without income; and
- Employees assuming ERISA works like state insurance, unaware that the federal overlay alters the rules governing it.
These challenges underscore the importance of working with an experienced ERISA lawyer.
Contact Us Today for Peace of Mind
Fighting for ERISA disability benefits requires both a thorough understanding of the law and a willingness to take on powerful insurance companies. At the Peace Law Firm, attorney John Peace has spent more than two decades guiding clients through ERISA claims. His years within the insurance industry provided him with a unique perspective on how companies attempt to avoid paying benefits. Today, he uses that knowledge to dismantle their tactics and stand beside employees until the benefits they’ve earned are finally delivered.
Our mission is simple: protect individuals against the misuse of power by insurance companies. With free consultations, decades of ERISA experience, and a proven track record in disability claims, John Peace is here so that South Carolina employees never face this fight alone. We represent real people on a contingency basis, meaning clients owe nothing unless the firm wins a settlement or verdict.
Contact us today for a free consultation, and let us explain how we can help you become the victor of your disability story.
